Japanese stocks have outperformed Asian stocks this yr as investors sit up for real corporate governance reforms that can force Japan Inc to be more efficient and productive while increasing shareholder returns.
Richard A. Brooks | AFP | Getty’s paintings
For the primary time in many years, Japanese stocks are back in fashion.
Benchmark over the past few weeks Nike 225 and Topix hit their highest levels in greater than 30 years as foreign investors poured into Japanese equities with a consistency rarely seen in no less than a decade.
After what turned out to be a false dawn ten years ago when Abenomics first raised hopes for corporate governance reform in Japan, many appear to think higher of the most recent measures taken by the Tokyo Stock Exchange.
“The recent initiative of the Tokyo Stock Exchange is a game-changer as it is going to challenge many firms that trade lower than a single price to book value to enhance profitability and support the share price,” said Singapore-based portfolio manager Oliver Lee. .
The Tokyo Exchange Group recently finalized the market restructuring rules. Amongst the most recent measures was one which ordered listed firms to “comply or explain” in the event that they are listed below level A price to book value ratio one – a sign that the corporate is probably not using its capital efficiently.
The exchange warned that such firms could face delisting as early as 2026.
A part of the optimism in Japanese equities stems from how specific and tangible the necessities of the Tokyo Stock Exchange are this time. Warren Buffett’s bullish calls for Japanese stocks also helped boost confidence amongst foreign investors.
The hope is that it is going to force Japan’s notoriously recalcitrant executives – who typically see shareholders as enemies – to greater capital efficiency and profitability. This might in turn result in a knock-on effect amongst other Japanese firms as the massive players start making changes.
“Until recently, the issue was that while there was a surge of healthy corporate activism, firms and executives still weren’t as proactive about listening to shareholder proposals,” Yunosuke Ikeda, chief equity strategist at CNBC, told CNBC last week.
![The strategist says investors probably want to move from China to Japan](https://image.cnbcfm.com/api/v1/image/107252326-16861098881686109885-29780459948-1080pnbcnews.jpg?v=1686111407&w=750&h=422&vtcrop=y)
The dimensions of change — or disappointment — is big.
The exchange said in March that half of its “top” listings – essentially the most liquid stocks with the most important market capitalization – and about 60% of its “standard” listings have a return on equity of lower than 8% and are trading at a price-to-book value of lower than one.
Price to book value is the ratio of the whole market value of an organization’s share price to its book value – the corporate’s net assets. Return on equity is a measure of an organization’s profitability.
These firms now need to indicate how they plan to enhance their capital efficiency as the information points suggest they will trade below the price of capital and are due to this fact unlikely to be capital efficient. Part of those rules require them to show how they’ve engaged investors and begin publishing public disclosures in English.
If an organization fails to fulfill the expanded listing criteria by the tip of the continued transition period and one other one-year “improvement period”, its securities might be placed under scrutiny and will face the prospect of being delisted inside six months.
“Withdrawal from the roster, any punishment or any enforcement is unlikely, but the excellent news in Japan is that there’s a peer pressure factor,” Nomura’s Ikeda said. “If rival firms make significant improvements in corporate governance, others shall be willing to follow suit.”
The long tail of abenomics reform
The goals are clear.
IN document published in late Marchthe operator of the Tokyo Stock Exchange wants to offer firms with sustainable growth and corporate value growth within the medium to long run by specializing in cost of capital and profitability on a balance sheet basis, relatively than simply sales and profit levels within the income statement.
In other words, they need real strategic change made in partnership with shareholders.
![Japanese stocks continue to rally, says Kei Okamura of Neuberger Berman](https://image.cnbcfm.com/api/v1/image/107248076-16854618671685461864-29677284799-1080pnbcnews.jpg?v=1685462287&w=750&h=422&vtcrop=y)
These reforms are a part of a broader, multi-year structural overhaul that could be traced back to Abenomics, an aggressive set of economic policies that the late Shinzo Abe launched in early 2010 when he was prime minister.
Corporate governance is the “third arrow” of the three basic principles of abenomics – the opposite two being monetary easing and monetary stimulus. The economic policies so widely advertised were aimed toward reviving economic growth and combating the chronic deflation that has plagued the world’s third largest economy because the Nineties.
While the initial euphoria in Japanese stock markets over Abenomics was short-lived in early 2010, investors now see the potential for a fundamental re-rating of Japanese stocks should recent corporate governance reforms take root.
Higher corporate governance is attracting increasingly international investors, including the latter, similar to Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway…
Asli M. Colpan
professor of corporate strategy at Kyoto University
“Investing in Japanese equities will not be investing in Japanese macro, it isn’t investing in themes,” said Shuntaro Takeuchi, manager of a San Francisco-based Japanese fund at Matthews Asia.
“Invests more in profit growth opportunities from improved margin, improved return on equity, improved total return.”
The Buffett effect
![Warren Buffett on raising shares in Japanese department stores: I was](https://image.cnbcfm.com/api/v1/image/107223791-16812957111681295704-28985200646-1080pnbcnews.jpg?v=1681296315&w=750&h=422&vtcrop=y)
Often called “sogo shosha”, Japanese shops are just like conglomerates and do business with a wide selection of products and materials and have helped bring the Japanese economy onto the world stage.
While their diversified business was a part of Buffett’s pull, some investors have criticized their complex operations and highlighted their increasing exposure to foreign risk as they expand internationally.
May’s Buffett disclosures helped spur 10 consecutive weeks of foreign net purchases of Japanese stocks. In response to data from the Ministry of Finance of Japan, within the last 10 weeks to June 3, foreigners bought Japanese shares with a net value of USD 57.8 billion.
“Investors, especially foreign investors, are under pressure to comply,” said Asli M. Colpan, a professor of corporate strategy at Kyoto University’s College of Management and Economics College.
“Higher corporate governance is attracting more international investors, including recent ones like Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway, and more international investors are putting more pressure on compliance – making a positive cycle,” she added.
Money wealthy, easy wins
And it’s already beginning to speak.
“Consequently of earnings growth, money flow generation and accumulation is now at a level where greater than 50% of corporations are net money and will be accumulating an excessive amount of money on their balance sheets,” said Takeuchi of Matthews Asia.
We’re probably only halfway to corporate reform.
Oliver Lee
East Spring Investments
“But the larger think about the long term is whether or not they’ll maintain their give attention to profitability by slashing underperforming business units and restructuring,” he added.
These are tougher decisions to make, but ultimately shall be the true gauge of corporate Japan’s appetite for reform, greater efficiency and productivity.
Nonetheless, the broader direction of long-term structural change in Japan is obvious.
In a world that struggles with stubbornly high inflation and faces anemic growth prospects, Japanese equity markets only add to their appeal – with the assistance of Japan’s accommodative monetary policy, its relatively more moderate inflation after years of chronic deflation, weak yen and relatively low cost valuations.
“We’re probably only halfway to corporate reform,” Lee said.