Did they or didn’t they? After Shayne selected to propose to Natalie Lee in season two, Shaina still made her feelings for him known. And after Shayne and Natalie didn’t get married within the finale, they tried to give their relationship one other shot off-camera. But Natalie revealed during Love Is Blind After the Altar that she discovered “flirtatious messages” between her boyfriend and Shaina about “what would have happened in the event that they ended up together.” The direct messages lead to the (second) demise of their romance, with Natalie explaining, “That is why we’re not together anymore.”
On After the Altar, Shaina insisted that it was “slander,” telling Shayne, “We have at all times been appropriate. We have never frolicked alone.” (They, on the time, they were indeed hanging out alone.)
During an interview with Entertainment Tonight, Natalie suggested “lots more” of Shayne and Shaina’s correspondences were left “on the cutting room floor.”
“I understand, when it comes to how much you possibly can really show in these three 45-minute-long episodes,” she said, “but what I do have is, again, text messages and emails with Shayne, talking about him unsending Instagram messages, deleting messages, and people DMs with Shaina, in order that’s something that I talked about that did not make the cut, that I believe form of would have helped with the story.”